Navigating the CMA’s new, stronger, consumer powers 

The CMA’s new consumer powers 

Last week, the CMA opened a consultation on ‘price transparency’ guidance, proposing strict interpretations of issues around ‘drip pricing’. This follows last year’s Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act (DMCC Act), which significantly strengthened UK consumer protection law. Among the headline reforms are new prohibitions around fake reviews, subscription contracts and ‘drip pricing’, as well as a major shift in its powers – the CMA will now be able to impose fines of up to 10% of global turnover. The changes are now, or will be shortly, coming into force.   

The CMA has been under high profile formal and informal political pressure in recent months to act in a more pro-growth way. However, at the same time, the government will want to see meaningful results for consumers, and to see the CMA make effective use of its new powers. Indeed, being ‘on the side’ of consumers is a way that the CMA can develop its public standing. It will need to achieve this while also demonstrating that it is applying its emerging more business-friendly approach to its consumer protection work.  

In April, the CMA announced its “approach” to the new consumer regime. The message was clear: the focus will be on encouraging and supporting compliance in the first year. However, this doesn’t mean enforcement is off the table. The CMA has signalled it will prioritise action against harmful practices that clearly breach the law, especially in areas of essential consumer spend. This means that there is a window to engage constructively with the CMA – most obviously on the recently opened price transparency consultation.   

What do businesses need to be aware of? 

Two of the most material developments are on: 

  • Fake reviews: The DMCC Act introduces new rules prohibiting the publication of reviews without taking ‘reasonable and proportionate’ steps to ensure they are genuine. Firms will need to develop – or evidence – thorough procedures. While the CMA has indicated a relatively light-touch approach at first (one fake review does not bring a publisher into non-compliance), businesses would benefit from closely reading the CMA guidance, and consider reaching out to the CMA on particularly difficult issues. The challenges are likely to be around what constitutes adequate detection mechanisms given the potential for AI to support detection of fake reviews, how stiff sanctions against those responsible for fake reviews need to be, and what overall success rate is required.   
  • Price transparency consultation (drip pricing and partitioned pricing): The CMA’s draft guidance, on which it is consulting until 8 September, interprets the law in ways that would mean many consumer-facing businesses across the economy would need to change their presentation of prices. While the law has been strengthened here, the existence of ‘drip pricing’ provisions in pre-existing law may mean the CMA is less willing to be restrained in its approach to enforcement. The consultation offers an opportunity to make evidence-based, consumer facing arguments, especially if firms seek to shift the CMA’s view.  The CMA will be running a webinar on 9 July, and roundtable events with industry associations later on 17 and 24 July.  Some notable points in the draft guidance include the following: 
    • All mandatory fees (such as delivery and admin fees) would need to be included in ‘running totals’ in baskets during the customer journey, as well as in advertising. A £20 dress sold online with a minimum £4.50 delivery fee, for instance, would need to be presented in advertising as being priced at £24.50 (the advert can of course note that this includes delivery).   
    • Some issues will require judgement – for instance, the draft guidance notes that in exceptional cases, firms may not need to provide as much information owing to space constraints in the type of communication used. The CMA’s view on what is reasonable here is likely to evolve through its case work and business engagement.  

How Flint can help 

Our team includes former CMA officials and regulatory experts who understand the DMCC Act, as well as how the CMA thinks about consumer journeys and consumer empowerment, concepts such as proportionality and reasonableness, and the CMA’s external environment. Our political and policy experts ensure our advice is informed by the wider context.  Please get in touch if you’d like to discuss further the CMA’s approach or how to engage with the CMA on the price transparency consultation or other issues. 

The authors of this blog, Nick Seaford, Tom Bibby and Karla Perca López all used to be economists at the CMA, and help firms navigate a range of competition and consumer protection issues.

Flint Enquiries

For enquiries, please contact us here